This study measured concentrations of two common phthalates (DEHP and DBP) in coffee powder and brewed coffee from different packaging types and extraction methods. DEHP levels were higher in beverages from professional espresso machines (median 6.65 ng/g) compared to Moka pots and home espresso machines, likely due to leaching from machine components. Despite these findings, all phthalate levels were below regulatory safety limits, and risk assessment showed no meaningful health concern for consumers drinking 1–6 cups of coffee daily.