This mixed-methods study developed the Quality in Nutrition Care Model for Dietitians (QUINCE-MOD) by surveying 114 healthcare consumers and 107 primary care professionals about 10 statements describing quality dietetic care. Consumers and professionals agreed on 7 of 10 statements but diverged on access to medical records, performance/safety information, and variation in care between dietitians. The QUINCE-MOD provides an evidence-based, complexity-informed framework for quality improvement in primary care dietetics.