This case report describes a newborn with neonatal severe hyperparathyroidism (NSHPT) due to a homozygous CASR gene mutation (c.222_226delGATAT). Despite this mutation being previously reported as unresponsive to cinacalcet, the patient maintained normocalcemia on cinacalcet and a calcium-restricted diet until 13 months of age, delaying parathyroidectomy until 17 months. The findings suggest that an empirical trial of cinacalcet should be considered in all NSHPT cases regardless of genotype, as it may delay the need for surgery.