This study demonstrates that corneal fibroblasts can revert to a keratocyte phenotype when placed in a normal stromal matrix, both after injury and after transplantation. Using a novel triple-transgenic mouse model for cell-lineage tracing, the authors show that keratocyte-derived cells populate corneal scars and that early-passage fibroblasts re-express keratocan when relocated to a healthy stroma. These findings highlight the plasticity of corneal fibroblasts and the critical role of the extracellular matrix in regulating cell phenotype, offering potential therapeutic avenues for reducing corneal scarring.