SEARCHOTHERpublic health, family medicine

other·public health, family medicine, internal medicine, research methods, epidemiology·PMC10603510

“For us, whatever we do is wrong, until we do something really good”: a qualitative study of the lived experiences of doctors from minority ethnic backgrounds in Scotland

BMJ Open · 5 authors, 6 centres

AI SUMMARY

FIDELITY 100%

This summary was generated by AI from a single paper. It has not been reviewed by a clinician and is not clinical advice. Verify against the source before acting on it.

AGENT 01 · STRUCTURED SUMMARY

TRACE TO SOURCE

“

TL;DR

This qualitative study used semi-structured interviews with 14 postgraduate doctors from minority ethnic backgrounds in Scotland to explore their training experiences. Participants reported facing barriers to social inclusion, microaggressions, negative pre-judgment, and systemic inequities such as disadvantages related to visa status.

Full summary

987 CHARS

This qualitative study, grounded in social constructivism, used semi-structured online interviews to explore the lived experiences of 14 postgraduate doctors from minority ethnic backgrounds in one Scottish Deanery. Thematic analysis revealed three main themes: barriers to authentic interpersonal connections leading to social exclusion; impacts on identity and belonging, including feeling negatively pre-judged and needing to conceal parts of their identity; and the perception of unjust systems, such as inequitable processes related to visa status and inadequate support for reporting discrimination. The authors discuss these findings through the lens of social learning theories and note the need for cultural intelligence development. Limitations acknowledged include potential researcher bias and the sensitive nature of the topic for participants. The study concludes that focused interventions to address systemic inequities and improve intercultural understanding are needed.

STUDY TYPE

other

SPECIALTY

public health

SUMMARISED BY

AI pipeline

FIDELITY CHECK

100% · A

ORIGINAL PAPER

PMC10603510

“For us, whatever we do is wrong, until we do something really good”: a qualitative study of the lived experiences of doctors from minority ethnic backgrounds in Scotland

BMJ Open

READ THE FULL PAPER

ABSTRACT

Abstract Objectives To evaluate the lived experiences of doctors from minority ethnic (ME) backgrounds during postgraduate medical training, in particular their experiences of discrimination (if any); any impact of intersectionality and perceptions on how ME doctors may be better supported in their learning and working environments. Design This was a qualitative study grounded in social constructivism, using semi-structured online individual interviews as the data collection method and an exploratory thematic analysis process. Setting Participants were recruited from postgraduate specialist medical training programmes within one Deanery (Scotland Deanery) in the UK. Participants Fourteen doctors in postgraduate medical specialist training, who self-identified as being from a ME background, were recruited into the study. Results Doctors from ME backgrounds faced: Barriers to authentic interpersonal connections, with a perceived lack of social inclusion in the workplace community. ME doctors faced challenges in earning others’ trust and experienced microaggressions and exclusion behaviours that affected their self-confidence. Impacts on identity and sense of belonging , with perceived challenges in being understood across diverse cultures. Doctors felt negatively pre-judged (by patients and colleagues), with additional challenges of being pre-judged in contexts of intersectionality; and ME doctors felt they needed to conceal parts of their identity in order to assimilate. Unjust systems—a playing field that is not level, where doctors felt unsupported and unable to effectively report/challenge discrimination. ME doctors perceived a lack of appropriate adjustments to the learning environment (e.g., fuller orientation) as well as inequitable processes (e.g., job and academic opportunities for those requiring visas). Conclusions Focused interventions to address unjust systems as well as improve intercultural awareness and understanding between all doctors may help to address some of the current inequities in medical education. Any such interventions require appropriate evaluation to determine their efficacy. Keywords: medical education & training, health education, qualitative research

CITATION EXPORT

Charu Chopra, Amudha Poobalan, Kathrine Gibson Smith et al.. “For us, whatever we do is wrong, until we do something really good”: a qualitative study of the lived experiences of doctors from minority ethnic backgrounds in Scotland. BMJ Open. (2023). https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2023-073733

AUTHORS

5 · 6 CENTRES

Charu Chopra, Amudha Poobalan, Kathrine Gibson Smith, Esther Youd, Peter Johnston

1NHS Education for Scotland, Edinburgh, UK
2Department of Immunology, NHS Lothian, Edinburgh, UK
3Institute of Applied Health Sciences, School of Medicine, Medical Sciences and Nutrition, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, UK
4University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, UK
5University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK
6Department of Pathology, NHS Grampian, Aberdeen, UK

Charu Chopra, Amudha Poobalan, Kathrine Gibson Smith et al.. “For us, whatever we do is wrong, until we do something really good”: a qualitative study of the lived experiences of doctors from minority ethnic backgrounds in Scotland. BMJ Open. (2023). https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2023-073733